Top 10 Best Toaster Ovens for Pizza & Reviews [2022 UPDATED]

Dear reader, if you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission to help support the blog - at no extra cost to you. And it never influences our product selection process. Thank you!

Top 10 Best Toaster Ovens for Pizza & Reviews [2022 UPDATED]

Toaster ovens have evolved over the years to do much more than just toast slices of bread. They have advanced to become very versatile, one of the kitchen appliances that are a must-have in any modern kitchen. For example, you can use a toaster oven for pizza, baking, preheating, frying, proof, toasting, and much more!

The advantages of countertop ovens are quickly becoming known to many, even those who own a conventional oven. There are many excellent indoor pizza ovens to pick from in place of the regular oven. So, if you want a toaster oven, you are in the right place.

We have sampled the best toaster ovens that offer the most convenience, performance, and versatility. Use the guidelines in this article to pick out the best toaster oven for your pizza nights!

Top 10 Best Toaster Ovens for Pizza and Detailed Reviews

Toaster ovens vary by model, versatility, capacity, material, technology, size, and many other features. When shopping, it's best to pick one depending on convenience and need. That said, let's take you through some of our best picks for toaster ovens. This selection has toaster ovens that offer more than what you find in the market.

1. Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven

The Cuisinart Chef's Convection Toaster oven is an all-in-one oven that offers versatility and efficiency at a high level. It boasts advanced heating technology with high-speed convection. Key features include:

Design

This digital toaster oven boasts a whopping 32 pounds and is 17inches deep, 21 inches wide by 11.5 inches high. Though large, we loved that it has an easy-to-read display, a backlit LCD screen, and front panel buttons to control the convection fan in the desired mode. In addition, it allowed dual cook mode; the lasagna baked perfectly, then the broiling feature gave it an excellent crisp exterior! Plus, the heat sensor managed the five heating elements to ensure no food got burnt.

Image Credits: daily.slickdeals.net

Performance

It offers high-speed performance with 15 cooking functions. For example, we easily toasted 9 slices of bread, and the device can bake a 13 inches pizza or even roast a whole chicken. Additionally, it has a feature that enables you to add 30 seconds of cook time, plus functionality for selecting temperature shade.

Ease of use and Cleaning

Cleaning was made easy with the four rack positions and a non-stick interior. Plus, I loved how the auto slide middle rack partially came out to make access easy.

Accessories

This Cuisinart includes two cooking racks, a 13-inch pizza stone, a 9-by-13-inch enamel baking pan, a broiling pan, and a crumb tray.

PROS

  • Cooks fast
  • Very versatile
  • User-friendly Interface
  • Great temperature accuracy

CONS

  • Too heavy
  • It doesn't come with an air fryer mode
  • Expensive

2. Breville Smart Oven Pro Toaster Oven

Breville BOV845BSS has an excellent design with state-of-the-art intelligence and an extensive interior, making it one of the best toaster ovens on the market.

Here are the key features that blew my mind:

Design

This Breville smart toaster oven is enormous and heavy. The dimensions are 18.5 x 14.5 x 11 and 22.8 pounds of weight. Given the size of this toaster oven, it might not be the most practical choice if you have a small kitchen.

This robust oven is made of brushed stainless steel and comes with a large display. It has an easy-to-use interface; with the time and temperature setting knob in large size.

Image Credits: thebrilliantkitchen.com

Performance

This versatile Breville toaster oven comes with 13 cooking functions, with excellent temperature accuracy. Making a 12-inches pizza with this toaster oven was a breeze; even at 450 F, the temperature remained exceptionally stable. Plus, it has a slow cook function that makes cooking various flavors possible.

Ease of use and cleaning

This smart oven is easy to use with features like a set of magnetic doors that pulls out the top rack to minimize the possibility of getting burnt. Additionally, the deep removable crumb tray made cleaning the interior very easy.

Accessories

The Breville toaster oven has an oven rack, an enamel broiling rack, an enamel baking pan, and a non-stick pizza pan.

PROS

  • Impressive cooking performance
  • Variety of cooking modes and built-in timer
  • Exceptional Temperature accuracy
  • User-friendly interface1-year warranty

CONS

  • Expensive
  • Not appropriate for small kitchen counter space
  • Requires a 2500-watt inverter 

3. Ninja SP201 Digital Air Fry Pro Countertop 8-in-1

Ninja SP201 Digital Air Fry Pro Countertop 8-in-1 is a great air fryer toaster oven. It's reliable and convenient for any small kitchen.

Design

The dimensions of this Ninja toaster oven are 20.21 x 15.33 x 8.15 inches. It's made of stainless steel, and the size can fit most countertops. In addition, we couldn't help but appreciate the in-built LCD touchscreen display and a unique hot flip cool-down function that minimized the possibility of getting burnt.

Image Credits: manuluize.com

Performance

The digital crisp control technology ensures evenly cooked food at the right temperature. The capacity can perfectly toast six slices of bread, but we found it hard to fit larger food like a chicken. Though it uses the power of up to 1800 watts, it can only cook frozen pizzas and not fresh dough.

The small ninja machine has eight cooking functions: air frying, Bake, Bagel, Broil, Toast, Dehydrate, air roasting, and Keep Warm. You can compare the performance of the best countertop convection ovens.

 Ease of Use

It is a simple machine to use, with its intuitive control panel. Unfortunately, cleaning proved to be an uphill task due to its small design.

Accessories

Ninja makes cooking convenient with accessories like a Crumb tray, Sheet pan, Air fry basket, and Wire rack.

PROS

  • Faster Cooking with Infrared Heating
  • Sleek and compact design
  • Doesn't make noise when in use
  • User friendly
  • It comes with pre-installed programs

CONS

  • Not easy to clean
  • Expensive

4. Panasonic FlashXpress

Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven is a convenient kitchen appliance. It stands out with infrared technology to ensure your pizza crust is perfectly cooked! Noteworthy features include:

Design 

This compact toaster oven weighs 7.5 pounds and is 12 x 13 x 10.5 inches. It has dual infrared cooking power and pre-programmed cooking functions for precision cooking. The oven door has a see-through screen, and the interior can fit 4 slices of bread or a 9-inch pizza.

Image Credits: amazon.com

Performance 

Infrared technology cooks food quickly. The best part was that we didn't have to preheat the oven before starting the cooking process. Furthermore, the exterior did not heat up as we cooked, which is an advantage as compared to other ovens.

This oven can bake, defrost, warm food, etc., and comes with a 1300 Watts cooking power. It has a heating system flowing through ceramic and quartz elements to ensure food is thoroughly cooked.

Ease of use and cleaning

We expected cleaning to be a hassle; fortunately, cleaning this small feller proved quite easy.

PROS

  • Cooks faster and evenly without preheating
  • Affordable
  • Easy-to-access controls
  • No radiation of heat when cooking
  • Easy maintenance and cleaning
  • Compact design

CONS

  • Small Interior space
  • Not enough timer duration
  • Difficult buttons
  • Can't bake or broil

5. Zojirushi ET-ZLC30 Micom

Elegant and beautiful is one way to describe Zojirushi ET-ZLC30 Micom. It's among the few toaster ovens in the market worth the money. Key features that Zojirushi impressed us with:

Design 

We had to take a minute just to appreciate how good this toaster oven looks. Micom Toaster Oven (ET-ZLC30) by Zojirushi comes in a sleek, compact design. The dimensions are 17″H x 19.375″W x 18″ D exterior and a 13.25" H x 13" W x 5" D interior. It is made of glass and presented in black color. It has a wide monochrome LCD with VA (Vertical Alignment) technology.

Image Credits: perfectforhome.com

Performance 

This kitchen appliance has 12 cooking functions and 8 heating elements to ensure that food is evenly cooked perfectly. Besides the good looks, we loved how easy it was to cook pizza due to its automatic rise-then-bake feature. Plus, it also has double thermostats for cooking precision.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

The Zojirushi is easy to clean and comes with a user-friendly interface.

Accessories

The accessories we got in the Zojirushi package include; Baking tray, crumb tray, Mesh rack, and Broil tray.

PROS

  • Sleek Design
  • Good Insulation
  • Advanced Heating for even cooking
  • Easy cleaning
  • 1-year warranty

CONS

  • Too slow to heat up and cooks slowly.
  • Short power cord length

6. KitchenAid KCO211BM Digital

Many users rave about how awesome the KitchenAid KCO211BM toaster oven is, and we agree with them. It is an excellent toaster oven for your pizza nights, with top-notch features that are a must-have in any kitchen. So let's explore some of those features:

Design

This toaster oven is not just stylish and small in size; it has a surprisingly big capacity compared to other toaster ovens at this price. KitchenAid KCO211BM has an exterior that is 11.25 inches high, 16.75 inches wide, and 13.5 inches deep. The interior measures around 8.5H x 15W x 12.75D.

Image Credits: tomsguide.com

Performance 

This KitchenAid toaster oven has a convection setting for great pizza and 9 cooking functions. It has a knob that controls time, toast shade, and time setting. It can bake, toast bread, warm, broiled vegetables, roast food, reheat, bagel, and any cookie. KitchenAid KCO211BM also functions as an air frying unit, and we were impressed at how much it performed better than most standard air fryers.

Easy to Use

The simple controls made this one of the easiest toaster ovens we tried. Plus, it's impossible not to appreciate how easy the non-stick interior makes cleaning enjoyable.

Accessories 

We got these accessories with the package; Metal drip, Baking Pan, Crumb tray, Grill rack, and Metal racks. 

PROS

  • Heats up fast and cooks perfectly
  • Versatile
  • Easy to clean
  • User friendly
  • 1-year warranty

CONS

  • No convection functionality
  • Exteriors highly heat up
  • Complex presets

7. Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach Countertop 31127 is one of the most convenient and affordable toaster ovens. It might just be the best cheap pizza toaster oven we have put to the test so far. But first, let's look at a breakdown of the features:

Design

Hamilton Beach toaster oven measures 15.24 x 18.74 x 9.41 inches and weighs 11.4 pounds. This innovative toaster might look small, but it can accommodate up to 4 slices of bread, a 12 inches pizza, and a 9" x 11" baking pan.

Image Credits: youtube.com

Performance

This affordable toaster oven has 3 cooking functions and a temperature range of 150-450. The fact that it doesn't have the popular convection technology was a bit of a downer. Nonetheless, it made up for it with an auto shut-off setting and a bell feature that alerted us when food was ready.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

The roll-up door and the removable crumb tray make cleaning a breeze. This small machine doesn't have complicated functions; cooking pizza was no hustle at all.

Accessories

In the package, you get a rack and a baking pan.

PROS

  • Varied temperature range
  • Cooks perfectly, including fresh pizzas
  • Fair price
  • Auto shut-off timer function
  • 1-year warranty

CONS

  • Small Size
  • It doesn't have digital controls
  • Missing convention technology
  • Preset cooking features are missing

8. The Oster TSSTTVMNDG-001

Oster boasts an appealing appearance, awesome design, and good functionalities. This toaster oven lives up to the rave of consumers and at an unbeatable price! Here are some of its unique features:

Design

The Oster toaster oven's dimensions are 23.8 x 20.15 x 15.1 inches″, and the interior is 15.75" wide and 16.36" deep. Like other toaster ovens, it is designed with brushed stainless steel. The design promotes convenience; when we open one door, the others open automatically. This huge toaster oven has a capacity big enough for a 14" pizza!

Image Credits: ebay.com

Performance

This toaster oven comes with convection turbo technology and 7 cooking functions. There is a convection fan that reduces cooking time by 30%. Additionally, the Oster toaster oven accommodates slow cooking with its preset temperature of 65.5°C. Noteworthy, this toaster oven will test your patience; it cooked too slow for my liking.

The cooking temperatures can rise to 450 degrees for quick cooking, and the auto shut-off features help food not to burn. For example, we baked a 14" pizza in 15 minutes, and it was not only perfectly cooked, but the crust also came out crispy and delicious. Take time to find out just how big a 14-inch pizza is to understand the capacity of this machine.

Ease of Use

This toaster oven is user-friendly, with an interior made of Teflon, which makes cleaning surprisingly easy. And the two-rack feature made cooking time flawlessly flexible!

Accessories

Oster toaster oven package includes a crumb tray and baking pan.

PROS

  • Large Capacity
  • Dual Baking Rack
  • Turbo Convection Technology
  • Sleek Design

CONS

  • Noisy convention fans
  • Cooks too slow
  • The power cord is too short.

9. Oster French Doors Countertop Oven

This digital convection toaster oven from Oster has a large capacity and superior features. With a heating temperature range from 150 to 450 F, it's one of the best toaster ovens on the market. Here are notable features the Oster Toaster Oven has:

Design

This digital convection toaster measures 19.72 w x 16.29 d x 11.33 h inches and weighs 20.3 pounds. It can fit a pan that is 2-inch-high, 10.5 inches wide, and 12.5 inches long. It can cook a 12-inch pizza, broil vegetables, toast 6 slices of bread, and even a whole chicken. The body is sturdy and durable, made of stainless steel.

Image Credits: youtube.com

Performance 

This toaster oven comes with convection turbo technology and 7 cooking functions. There is a convection fan that reduces cooking time by 30%. Additionally, the Oster toaster oven accommodates slow cooking with its preset temperature of 65.5°C.

It also comes with pre-installed cooking functions. Heat distribution was disappointing when toasting bread.

Ease of Use

It has an interior light that lets you view food as it cooks. The digital control panel is user-friendly, and the interior is easy to clean.

Accessories 

Oster toaster oven kit includes a crumb tray and baking pan.

PROS

  • Compact Design
  • Cleaning is easy
  • Comes with Convection heating
  • Very robust

CONS

  • Electric Cord is short
  • Heat Distribution is not uniform

10. BLACK+DECKER Toaster Oven

This Black and Decker Toaster oven offers the excellence of a convection oven at a very affordable price. One thing we did not expect is for it to offer such reliable functionality for making pizza, especially considering how low it costs.

Design

The dimensions of this toaster oven are 16.5 "X12.5" X9.5″, with a capacity that accommodates a 9″ x13″ oven pan size. The toaster oven requires a voltage converter and uses 1150 Watts of power. It has two rack positions; unfortunately, it has very few cooking functions compared to other toaster ovens we tried.

Image Credits: kitchenandcookware.com

Performance

Unlike other toaster ovens, this Black and Decker toaster oven has 4 cooking functions: keeping food warm, broiling, baking, and toasting. On the upside, we loved that it has a predictable shade selection when toasting bread. The preset timer is 60 minutes; sadly, it stopped halfway.

Ease of use and clean

The oven has a user-friendly interface and is easy to clean with a removable crumb tray.

Accessories

The package had a broil rack, a toasting rack, and a baking pan.

PROS

  • Not pricy
  • Bakes frozen pizzas.
  • Cleaning is easy

CONS

  • Uneven heat distribution
  • Difficult knobs
  • Insulation is very bad
  • Noisy

Buying Guides – How to Choose the Best Toaster Oven?

Let us now take a look at a breakdown of what to look for when shopping for a toaster oven:

a) Space

Before purchasing any toaster oven, it is mandatory to consider whether or not you have enough room for it. You can find top-notch toaster ovens in both small and large sizes.

b) Design 

Aesthetics are an important factor to consider when buying a toaster oven. But remember, it's going into your kitchen so that the appeal will remain a priority. For a modern design, go for digital machines with a sleeker appeal.

c) Accessories 

Take time to check what is included in the package you want to purchase. For example, most toaster ovens come with a removable crumb tray, at least one rack, and extra pans. Check if the parts are dishwasher safe; if yes, it helps with the maintenance of your machine.

d) Additional Features 

Toaster ovens that have glass doors make viewing food easier. Try and ensure your choice of toaster oven has an air frying rack or pizza stone for a smooth cooking process. An interior light is one extra feature that just makes a difference.

e) Settings

Now, when it comes to settings, it's important to consider what you want it to do for you. For example, are you trying to replace several appliances with one? Then go for a toaster oven with more cooking settings.

Conclusion

The new multi-tasking countertop ovens in the market are very versatile. They can bake, broil, roast, reheat, air fry, proof, and even dehydrate. It's about preference because there is something for everyone with these versatile toaster ovens.

Featured Image Credits: delish.com

author-brooklyncraftpizza

Author

JAMES BURNEY

I’m the content manager for BrooklynCraftPizza.com, and I love writing about kitchen appliances. I’m passionate about cooking at home, and I’m extremely excited about modern kitchen appliances. I like to analyze markets and products, and then turn them into informative blogs for anyone who wants to cook at home quickly. Thanks for reading!