How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge? (Exact & Detailed Answer)

Dear reader, if you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission to help support the blog - at no extra cost to you. And it never influences our product selection process. Thank you!

How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge

It’s important to know how long is pizza good for in the fridge because you don’t want to get sick! This blog post will help you understand how long does pizza last and what you can do with it after that. 

– The exact answer: Pizzas are safe to eat up until FOUR DAYS past their expiration date. If the package has a use by date, then this is when they should be eaten or risk getting food poisoning. 

How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge (Correct Answer)

Pizza is an iconic dish that has been around for centuries. Many people enjoy pizza as a meal or snack, but there are some who want to know the answer to how long pizza will be good in the fridge.

The answer for question “how long is pizza good for in the fridge” depends on what type of toppings you put on your pizza and whether it was made at home or bought from a restaurant.

There are also other factors such as whether you refrigerated it when it came out of the oven or left it at room temperature. Read below to find out more! 

The answer to this question is not very simple, but it’s important for consumers to know. The process of making pizza affects how long it will be good in the fridge.

How-Long-Is-Pizza-Good-For-In-The-Fridge-correct-ans

The more toppings on your pizza, the shorter its life span. On average, a whole wheat crust with cheese and sauce can last 5-7 days in the refrigerator while a thin crust with just cheese and sauce will last 3-4 days before going bad.

If you are unsure if your food has gone bad or not, look out for these signs: moldy spots on top of your pizza or an off odor when you open up the box.

Pizza is an iconic dish that has been around for centuries with many people enjoying this tasty food item in their day-to-day lives. It can come in all shapes and sizes, but we’re focusing on the type of pizza that comes in the crust with toppings, sauce and cheese.  

Pizza that’s plain (with only cheese) can be stored in the fridge not more than two days past its expiration date. This is because there are no other ingredients to make it last longer.

On the other hand, pizzas made at home or bought from restaurants with many toppings will keep for about four days if kept cold in the refrigerator after you bring it home.

This is because there are more ingredients present to keep it good for a longer period of time. If you do choose to eat the pizza on its fourth day, make sure you reheat it first!  

After the number of days in the fridge pass, you should not eat it because it can cause food poisoning.

If you’re wondering how long pizza is good for in the freezer , then there’s a simple answer: up to three months . If stored properly, this will keep your pizza tasting great and free from bacteria that may make you sick.

Simply put your pizza into the freezer as soon as possible and store it properly to avoid any mishaps with it going bad sooner than expected!

It’s also important to know when you should throw out your frozen pizzas so they don’t go beyond their expiration date.

If at any point in time your pizza starts growing mold or develops a foul smell, then this means harmful bacteria has grown on your food and you should immediately throw it out.

If you want to know how long pizza is good for without refrigeration, then there isn’t an exact answer because time varies from pizza to pizza. In general, pizzas lose their desired taste and become dry after three hours if left at room temperature.

There are ways in which you can make your pizza last for longer periods of time without refrigeration such as using ingredients that have high water content but they’re not a solution to keep your food fresh for a longer period of time.

If you do leave your food out for too long past its expiration date, then it can cause severe stomach problems or nausea rather than getting food poisoning that’s severe enough to land you the hospital!

It’s important to know how long is pizza good for in the fridge before eating it so you can prevent unwanted illness and stomach aches.  

How to store pizza in the fridge

Now that you know how long does pizza last, how do you store pizza? It’s important, but it’s not as complicated as you think.

Store pizza in the coldest part of your refrigerator, ideally in a sealed plastic bag.

If you put it directly in the fridge drawer, it will go dry and crisp until moisture evaporates off since there is limited air flow.

According to the USDA, pizza in sealed freezer bag in the refrigerator should be eaten within 2 days.

How-to-store-pizza-in-the-fridge

But this really depends on how much you will eat it in these 2 days, if you are going to eat all of it before then I suggest heating it up or eating it at room temperature so that you don’t have to throw away half a day’s worth of food.

I’ll say that if you’re not sure whether its still safe to eat after being in the fridge for two days, just cut off one slice and see whether there is any strange smell or bad color changes or mold starting ,if not then its probably fine but I always recommend checking anyways.

If you place your pizza directly on the rack, it may dry out and become tough.

If you want to save room in the fridge, keep it on a plate or pan instead of directly on the rack.

I suggest not heating up your leftover pizza from the fridge because most times they will come out soggy and lacking flavor. But if I’m being honest with myself my favorite is cold pizza straight from the fridge but its also delicious at room temp so go for whatever option makes you happy!

Guide to reheat leftover pizza

Reheating leftover pizza is an art form that can take years to master, or you can just follow these simple steps. Just kidding! Reheating leftover pizza takes no time at all; it’s actually one of the easiest things in your cooking arsenal.

You don’t need any special skills or equipment, and you probably already have everything you need on hand right now.

And even if reheated pizza doesn’t turn out perfectly every time (it won’t), there are plenty of ways to make it taste good enough for another meal! So let’s get started with some helpful tips on how to reheat leftover pizza like a pro.

The key to a great reheated pizza is timing.

The best way to reheat leftover pizza is by placing them on a baking sheet in a preheated oven set to 350F for about 5 minutes per side. If you want the cheese layer to become golden-brown again, try putting them under an overhead broiler for a few minutes.

Of course you can also use the microwave too , but it may cause the crust to become soggy and spongy (it will taste fine, though). Just make sure that you don’t put them inside for more than about 15-20 seconds per slice or else they may start to steam and become rubbery.

I mean, you could throw the leftover slices in the microwave and call it a day, but that will likely ruin your favorite toppings and leave your crust soggy.

If you have a little more time on your hands, though, there are actually four methods of reheating pizza that I highly recommend trying out: baking in a conventional oven , putting it under the broiler , cooking it on the stovetop , or reheating multiple slices at once in a skillet .

Each one has its own advantages and disadvantages, so if you’re looking for something specific, this guide might help narrow down which method is best for you!

And as always with food safety issues, remember that it’s okay to experiment with reheating techniques without worrying too much about ruining your pizza. If the end result ends up terrible, you can always make something else out of whatever you’ve got left, or just set aside those slices for snacking on.

The most important thing is to avoid eating spoiled food, so if your leftover slices aren’t perfect, don’t stress! Just throw them away and get creative with your cooking the next time around. Or make a sandwich.

If you are microwaving your pizza, it can be reheated on high for about 1 minute per slice.

But the most common method is to bake/grill which will better bring out its flavors.

Remember, leftovers taste best when they are heated up so that they have that fresh-from-the-oven flavor again!

Place leftover slices on a baking sheet or in a cast iron skillet and heat at 350°F for 8 to 10 minutes, flipping halfway through.

Besides understanding how long is pizza good for in the fridge, you need to know the methods of reheating pizza, here we will go into those ways.

Reheat In a Traditional Oven

If you don’t have a toaster oven, I recommend using the classic method that most pizza restaurants use.

Heat your oven up to 500°F and place the slices directly on its rack for 5 minutes, then flip them over and return them to the oven for an additional 3 or 4 minutes.

This is my favorite method because it also crisps up the crust and makes it taste like it just came out of a brick-oven!

Reheat In The Toaster Oven

The perfect weapon against unappetizing leftover pizza: If you own a regular under-the-counter toaster oven , then this is definitely your best bet at heating up those slices without making them soggy or rubbery. Just follow the 5-3-2 rule for toaster oven reheating : five minutes on high , three minutes on medium, and two more minutes on low.

The Toaster Oven Method

Leftover pizza can last in the fridge for about two days max . After that, you should throw it away or feed it to your pet (if they will eat it). The safest way to keep them around longer would be to freeze them. Just wrap the slices individually with tinfoil/plastic wrap, then put them into a plastic container or sealable bag.

But honestly I think this is one of those times when if freezing makes you feel better then go for it! Just make sure that you mark the date and time so that you don’t forget when your pizza was frozen, and how long it’s been around.

Besides reheating the slices, you can also save those extra toppings by freezing them as well! Just put small amounts of sauce and/or cheese on a baking sheet , then place them in the freezer until they’re solid.

Then just transfer them into a sealable container or plastic bag for longer-term storage! To defrost, just heat up some water in a pot, then submerge the contents of your container into that warm water for about 10 minutes.

And if you want to avoid having too much leftover pizza in the first place… …just make sure to charge everyone who has promised to come over this weekend! You know what I mean.

The better to reheat your leftovers with. 🙂

I hope that this guide helps you get maximum enjoyment out of your future leftover pizza meals! If you have any other favorite methods for heating up slices besides “how long is pizza good for in the fridge”, then let me know in the comments below!

Reheating Pizza in a Skillet

Pizza slices are best reheated in a skillet on the stovetop .

To get started, preheat your pan over medium heat for about 3 minutes with 1 tablespoon of either butter or olive oil. You can use more or less depending on how many slices you’re reheating at once (1 tablespoon is good for 2 to 4 slices).

Grill it like you mean it! Then place as many slices as will fit onto the hot surface and grill them until they become crispy and browned again (about 5 minutes per side).

Flip them, then crisp up those other sides. After that, transfer the cheesy triangles to a plate and microwave for 1 minute , repeating as needed until all your slices have been reheated properly.

Pizza slices reheated in a skillet become crispier than their microwaved or toaster oven counterparts because of the scorching hot pan. The cheese melts and gets all crispy-crunchy, while the crust becomes flaky and chewy once again!

At this point you can add any other toppings that were originally on your slices, then dig in and enjoy! 🙂

Reheating pizza in a pan is also great if you want to avoid having to scrub your crisping trays/toaster oven pans after using them. Just leave it alone for 1 hour, then wash with warm soapy water (you should be able to remove everything easily at that point).

Don’t Have A Pan? Just use Microwave

If you don’t want to dirty up your skillet/pan for reheating pizza, then that’s okay!

You can use the microwave instead. Just put in on a plate and cover it with plastic wrap , making sure that you vent out most of the steam by poking holes all over the plastic wrap using a fork or skewer .

Microwave it for about 3 minutes per slice (depending on how many slices you’re reheating at once), then repeat if necessary until they’re nice and warm again.

If you don’t own a microwave , then just heat up some water in a pot, submerge your slices into the hot water, then repeat as needed until they’re all heated through.

You can also try heating them atop parchment paper placed on a baking sheet in the oven, though they may not be as crispy-crunchy as you’re used to.

You can also reheat slices by placing them on a panini press or grill for about 5 minutes per side (depending on your strength of machine).

You can also cook them up in an electric skillet , though keep in mind that every time you open it, more moisture will escape and your pizza will become less crisp. So cook it slowly if this is what you choose! 🙂

How long it’s safe to eat leftover pizza

A general rule-of-thumb is that it’s safe to eat leftover pizza from a restaurant for up to 5 days .

However, if it’s been in your fridge for 2 or 3 days before you take it out of the fridge, then you should slice and re-heat the slices again.

And if you’ve had a whole pie in there for a week or longer , then I’d recommend throwing it out. It’s going to be dryer and less flavorful by this point, while its crust may also have gone stale! But hey… If it tastes fine, then eat away at your own risk! 😉

What about freezing Pizza? Is that okay?

Pizza is usually safe to eat for about 3 months when frozen (that’s how long is pizza good for in the fridge).

However, if you’re going to be storing the pizza slices in your freezer for longer than that, then I recommend wrapping each slice p separately before putting it into a Ziploc bag. That way they won’t stick together or dry out as easily!

You can also use aluminum foil to wrap up your slices , which will help them last even longer. Just make sure that you label what they are and their date of production so you eat them first. 😉

If the crust becomes too hard once frozen, just let it thaw on the countertop or stove top. It’ll taste fine after being heated up again!

Storing Your Pizza and Keeping It Fresh Longer

To retain the taste and texture of your pizza longer, wrap it up in aluminum foil then place into a Ziploc bag once you’ve taken it out of the oven.

You can also use plastic wrap if you don’t have any aluminum foil available to you. But keep in mind that plastic is not as good at keeping moisture out, so this may cause your slices to dry up more quickly. You can fix this by placing each wrapped slice into an airtight container .

As for where to store them inside your refrigerator , try to put them on separate shelves while they’re still hot (this will help prevent their juices from mixing together). You should also try to do this within 1-2 hours after eating the slice(s).

If you don’t think you’ll be able to eat your slices within a few hours, then place them inside the fridge as soon as possible so they can cool down quickly. You can also re-heat it again if you want , though this may cause the flavor and texture of the slice(s) to become less crispy and dryer (since moisture will escape each time you heat it up).

You should only refrigerate pizza that’s been cooked completely or else bacteria could start growing on its surface.  Once you take it out of the oven, make sure that all of its toppings have had enough time to cook through (until any bubbling has stopped), otherwise some parts of your slice(s) may be undercooked (this could make you sick).

Take note though… If your pizza crust is super-thin (like the kind you see at fast food restaurants), then it may not be fully cooked inside just yet, which could also lead to bacteria growth. So I recommend cooking extra until the dough becomes browned and crispy.

You’ll still have plenty of time to cool it down after that before refrigerating or freezing! 🙂

FAQs related to How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge

Is pizza good after 5 days in fridge?

Yes, it’s fine to eat.

Is the mold on the pizza my health concern?

No, but make sure you do not consume any moldy or suspect piece of food, especially if you are immune suppressed.

If I were to put a Pizza in the Fridge for 10 days will it be bad when i take it out again?

No, not at all! Since refrigerated or frozen pizzas have preservatives that prevent them from spoiling after being refrigerated or frozen they can safely stay there for many months with no significant change. But I would recommend eating within 2 weeks so its fresh and tasty when you do!

Can pizza expire?

Yes, it can. Once pizza is cooked, it should be eaten within two days. The longer pizza sits out, the greater the risk of food poisoning.

Pizza that has been sitting in the fridge for more than two days is not safe to eat. Pizza that has been frozen can be stored in the fridge for up to four days. Reheat your pizza before eating it to make sure that it is cooked all the way through and hot.

If you are not sure if your pizza is still good, throw it away. It is better to be safe than sorry when it comes to food poisoning.

How can you tell if pizza is bad?

You can tell if pizza is bad or spoiled by doing a smell test, color change/damage check, and listening for strange sound. If any of these indicate spoilage then it should be discarded.

Does pizza get spoiled overnight? Is it safe to eat it?

Pizza can spoil overnight if it is not stored properly. If pizza is left out on the counter, it will become soggy and the crust will start to harden. The longer pizza sits out, the greater the risk of food poisoning.

The food poisoning risk is high because bacteria can grow quickly on moist, warm food. Pizza that has been stored in the fridge for more than two days is not safe to eat. If you must eat the pizza, make sure to reheat it until it is steaming hot.

If you are not sure if your pizza is still good, throw it away. It is better to be safe than sorry when it comes to food poisoning. Reheat your pizza before eating it to make sure that it is cooked all the way through and hot.

After 5 days in the fridge is pizza still good?

No, I’d say at most you can keep it for 2-3 days in the refrigerator. The oxidation process speeds up when food is kept cold (in or out of the refrigerator). You should freeze your leftovers.

How long can pizza sit out?

Pizza is safe to eat even after it’s been sitting out for a while. If the pizza has been sitting out for more than two hours at room temperature, it’s not worth eating. You can still eat it cold or reheat it, but the quality won’t be as good as freshly made pizza.

Pizza is one of those foods that tastes even better the next day. If you’re not sure how long can pizza sit out, it’s always better to err on the side of caution and throw it away.

Can i freeze pizza hut pizza?

Pizza Hut® does not recommend freezing our pizzas. However, we know that some of our customers choose to do so. If you decide to freeze your Pizza Hut® pizza, please follow these instructions:

1) Place your pizza in the freezer as soon as possible after purchase

2) Eat within 2-3 months for best quality

3) Remove pizza from all packaging before freezing

4) Wrap pizza tightly with aluminum foil or place in a freezer bag to prevent freezer burn

5) When ready to eat, thaw pizza overnight in the refrigerator

6) For best results, reheat pizza in the oven at 425 degrees Fahrenheit for 18-22 minutes

7) Do not microwave your pizza as this will result in a less than ideal texture

And Pizza Hut has many types of pizza with different crusts, you can refer to it here.

Can you freeze sliced pepperoni?

Sliced pepperoni can be frozen, but it’s not the best idea. The texture will change and it won’t be as good as fresh pepperoni. If you do decide to freeze sliced pepperoni, make sure to wrap it tightly in aluminum foil or place it in a freezer bag. It will last for up to two months in the freezer.

Can you leave cheese bread out overnight?

Yes, I would say after about 4 hours it should be ok.

Can I eat pizza from 6 days ago?

Yes, you can if it is still kept at the right temperature (refrigerator). Although after a few days of storage it will not be as good as having fresh warm pizza.

How long can you keep pizza in the fridge?

You can keep pizza in the fridge for about 3-5 days without any problem. I would recommend that you eat within 1 week so its fresh and tasty when you do!

Can you get sick from old pizza?

Well, eating old pizza is probably not a good idea. But if you consume an otherwise healthy food that happens to contain some bacteria, there’s no reason you should get sick from it. If this concerned you then just keep in mind that microwaving food in general tends to “activate” the bacteria present in the microwave and cause it to reproduce faster than normal situations would allow for.

What is the 2-hour rule for food?

The two-hour rule is a good starting point when it comes to food safety. If perishable food has been out of refrigeration for more than approximatly 2 hours, and the room temperature is above 90 degrees F, then it may not be safe to eat.

Can you eat pizza left out for 5 hours?

Most of the time yes. It depends on how hot it was when you took it out, if it cooled down quickly after leaving the oven or not, and so on. But in general I would say yes, most likely its fine to eat.

How long can you keep Papa John’s pizza in the fridge?

Well, the dough contains dairy so you should try to use it as soon as possible or freeze it so its fresh when you cook.

Can pepperoni last 9 days after opening?

Pepperoni is a cured meat which means that naturally occurring bacteria will be unable to grow on it. So if stored properly indefinitely, no it won’t spoil.

How long can a pizza stay in the car?

1-2 hours. If you have a warm day, it could be longer, if its very cold outside then probably less time. Basically just keep an eye on it!

Conclusion about How Long Is Pizza Good For In The Fridge

With the right care, your pizza can last four days in the fridge. You should read this blog post again to find out how long you should store it and what will happen if you don’t follow our guidelines.

We highly recommend that you reheat any leftover pizza within 24 hours of its initial preparation date–both microwave or oven methods work well with this dish! If left unheated after two days (72 hours), however, there is a risk that harmful microbes could grow because food safety standards are not always met due to bacterial growth during refrigeration. 

Now go forth and enjoy all those delicious pizzas from tomorrow night’s dinner party without worry about spoilage!

As long as your pizza is still fresh when you first take it out of the fridge , then it should be okay in your refrigerator for up to 4 days . Of course, if you never do manage to eat within this time frame, then I recommend freezing it instead so that it can last even longer! 🙂

Read more: How Much To Tip Pizza Delivery Driver?

Top 100 Amazing & Fun Pizza Facts

author-brooklyncraftpizza

Author

JAMES BURNEY

I’m the content manager for BrooklynCraftPizza.com, and I love writing about kitchen appliances. I’m passionate about cooking at home, and I’m extremely excited about modern kitchen appliances. I like to analyze markets and products, and then turn them into informative blogs for anyone who wants to cook at home quickly. Thanks for reading!