13 Best Pizza Places in Key West, FL [Newest 2022]

Dear reader, if you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission to help support the blog - at no extra cost to you. And it never influences our product selection process. Thank you!

13 Best Pizza Places in Key West, FL [Newest 2022]

Are you looking for the best pizza places in Key West? We got you. In the culinary world, Key West is well known for serving the most delicious seafood. Nevertheless, you may not be surprised that this little island is packed with some tasty pizza places. So, if you are in the mood for a thin, crispy slice of pizza, or a heaping deep dish of saucy, cheesy deliciousness, our list is sure to have the spot for you. 

1. Onlywood Pizzeria

Price: $15.50-$22.50 (Menu)

Address: 13 1/2 Rear Duvall, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-735-4412

If you love having your pizza accompanied by some great wine, Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria is the place for you! It is a traditional trattoria-style spot that first opened in 2012. What sets this place apart is the relish of authentic wood-fired thin-crust Italian pizza they offer.

All the pizzas from Onlywood are made using homemade mozzarella, which is made using an ancient recipe. Onlywood uses the best tomato sauce, San Marzano, imported from Italy. They also have a brick oven made from lavic materials from the Vesuvius in Napoli. No wonder their Neapolitan pizza style is loved and found to be the best on the island.

Image Credits: onlywoodkw.com

Besides offering the best pizza in Key West, they also create fantastic pasta, lasagna, and fresh local seafood. If you're on this island, you should visit this pizzeria, and you will definitely love their pizza.

2. Mr. Z’s Old Town

Price: $11-$24 (Menu)

Address: 501 Southard St (at Duval St.), Key West, FL, United States

Phone Number: +1 305-296-4445

Mr. Z's is another well-known spot serving more than just great pizza. The authentic Italian sandwiches are as much of a draw, particularly their cheesesteak. You can get the best of both worlds here.

Despite being busy, the staff in this place are polite, and it's visible from the food that they put all their passion into the recipes they prepare. So if you're feeling pizza or cheesesteaks and need it customized to your liking, then you can order from Mr. Z's.

Image Credits: st.depositphotos.com

The place is open every day of the week and until 4:00 am on weekends if you are craving a late-night slice of pizza. However, you should note that they accept cash only.

3. Duetto Pizza & Gelato

Price: $21.50-$32.95 (Menu)

Address: 540 Greene St (Ann st.), Key West, FL, United States

Phone: +1 305-848-4981

If you're craving a slice of pizza and you are near downtown key west, Duetto Pizza & Gelato is undoubtedly one of the best pizzerias you can find.

Voted as one of TripAdvisor's best pizza eateries in America, Duetto Pizza & Gelato delivers a variety of fresh salads, pizzas, and many other Italian goodies. All their pizzas are Italian style, and they come in 16-inch pies with 6 slices.

Image Credits: tripadvisor.com

Again all their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients, and you will have different flavors to choose from. Besides having the best pizza, the place also has a welcoming and cozy environment.

Moreover, they have amazing customer service, which is why customers gravitate to this place. Duetto Pizza & Gelato is open daily from 11 am to 10 pm.

4. Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria

Price: $12-$22 (Menu)

Address: 5620 MacDonald Ave, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 305-296-4999

Roostica is a wood-fired pizzeria widely believed to be a favorite to many in Key West. It features mouthwatering red, white, and stuffed pizzas made using only the freshest ingredients.

The dough used to make the pizzas is made with only soft-grain flour, yeast, water, and sea salt. Plus, only Italianplum tomatoes, mozzarella di buffalo, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil are used to top it.

image source: roastica.com

We love that the place has an open kitchen design that allows you to watch as your pizza is carefully and authentically prepared. Again the overall design of this place feels hip and high-end, providing an enjoyable dining experience. 

Furthermore, this place offers great pizza and a large selection of crisp salads, antipasti, and wine. Don't forget to try their famous Lemoncello wood-fired wings, served on Sundays, or the gravy and meatballs served family style.

5. Moon Dog Cafe

Price: 16.50- 17.50 (Menu)

Address: 823 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 802-732-8453

The Moon Dog Cafe is a perfect breakfast, lunch, and dinner place in Key West, FL. Although this place is commonly known for offering the best breakfast on the island, it also has some of the best pizzas in Key West.

The best part is that, unlike most pizza places, the Moon Dog Cafe offers lots of gluten-free and healthy vegan pizza options. They also have a variety of topping options, including Moroccan Lamb, Shrimp, Bacon, or Fig and Gorgonzola cheese.

Image Credits: tripadvisor.com

What fascinates us the most about this place is that thay have a bakery on-site if you want any freshly baked goodies. This is the place to be if you want an adorable all-around outpost with outdoor seating, a full bar, and many murals.

6. Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria

Price: $13 to $24(Menu)

Address: 516 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 305-900-7035

It started in 2014, making pizza from a refurbished vintage troller and developed into a full-service restaurant. The restaurant surprisingly utilizes centuries-old artisan traditions to make its outstanding pizzas.

What's more, they leave their dough to rise for thirty-six hours. More so, they use fresh ingredients, including Mozzarella di Bufala and San Marzano tomatoes providing the pizzas with a delicate, rich flavor and Neopolitan crust texture.

Image Credits: thekeywester.com

The pizzeria makes a basic pizza iconic. Hence no doubt other recipes are excellent. Their pizza crusts cannot disappoint you. It is wood-fired, crispy, and thin, providing the right crispiness and chewiness. However, if you are confused about what to order, ask for their incredible honey bacon pizza. You will love it!

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria is known for its Sicilian pizzas, which are crispy and light, making them a must-eat. They provide different desserts and salads, which are impressive. On top of that, their services are exceptional.

Additionally, the restaurant is positioned at the center of Key West, 1/2 block off Dual Street. The spot is lively and plays rock tunes to entertain its customers. Plus, the area has sidewalk seating for you to rest. Their specialty is the Honey Bacon Pizza. Do not miss out on this pizza from the best pizza place.

7. Big John’s Pizzeria

Price: $11 to $30 (Menu)

Address: 1103 Key Plaza Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-293-9576

Despite not remaining as famous as other pizzerias in Key West, Big John's pizzas are perfect. The restaurant is recognized for its excellent service, friendly staff, reasonable pricing, and fast delivery. Its New York-style pizzas will leave you asking for more. Plus, their garlic rolls are perfect.

Image Credits: slicelife.net

Moreover, their Buffalo Chicken and vegan pizza are a must for pizza lovers. Their taste is excellent and something to look forward to when you visit Key West. The restaurant is known for its fresh salads with good dressing!

8. Seaside Cafe At The Mansion

Price: $15 to $27 (Menu)

Address: 1400 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 305-340-8167

Known for its lobster pizza, Sea Side Cafe at Mansion is famous for its artisan wood-fired pizzas, which are outstanding. The restaurant boasts of its Hot Honey Salami pies and Duval Street Corn. For lobster lovers, these lobster pizzas are a must-try.

Image Credits: dealerfire.com

The view from the restaurant is just exceptional! Its position just a few steps from the warm Atlantic Ocean provides you a charming historical and tourist scenery. The owners, father, and son, are family and pet friendly. That's why the cafe is famous for its friendly services, including welcoming staff and exceptional services. So pop in for your lunch and shade when you visit the best Key West beaches on your best day.

9. Angelina’s Pizzeria

Price: $10 to $25 (Menu)

Address: 208 Duval St #6508, Naval Air Station Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 949 536 5200

Key West recognizes Angelina's Pizzeria as one of the best cheese pizza cafes in the area. Positioned at the center of Downtown Key West, the cafe boasts of welcoming and friendly staff, honest pricing, and a vibrant and fun atmosphere. The restaurant provides Hawaiian, meat lovers, veggie lovers, and cheese pizza. Their New York-style pizzas are out of this world.

If you feel like pizza, pop into the cafe to enjoy New york style pizzas. You can order by the slice or the whole pizza to enjoy with your family and friends. You can get gluten-free pizza at Angelina's Pizzeria for gluten-free pizza lovers. Besides, you can have wings, salads, calzone, and lasagna.

Image Credits: squarespace.com

Another exciting aspect of Angelina's Pizzeria is various hot sauce alternatives by Peppers of Key West. Their garlic bread is an excellent addition to the orders in the cafe. The exciting decor, with a white and black checkered floor, vintage arcade games, and sticker-covered walls, makes the restaurant enjoyable. When you visit Key West, consider Angelina's Pizzeria for your New York-style pizza, including cheese pizza and other delicacies depending on your mood.

10. Off-The-Hook Grill

Price: $10 to $22 (Menu)

Address: 920 Caroline St Stop #1 on the Duval Loop, Key West, FL 33040-7475

Phone: +1 305-741-7980

Off The Hook Grill in Key West is a cozy and attractive pizza eatery. You find food inspired by various flavors around the globe. Moreover, the cafe can tailor personal pizza for vegan and gluten-free consumers.

The cafe boasts locally sourced pizzas and seafood in one place. Their long menu provides their customers with plenty of foods to select from depending on their mood and taste. For example, you can order lobster pizza, lobster mac, roll, and cheese for lobster lovers. Other favorites include fried green tomatoes and scallops over the pork belly. In addition, they have a lovely blueberry mint key lime pie dessert.

Image Credits: offthehookkeywest.com

Their toppings are classic, including Greek and Italian, and they offer BBQ Pork, Duck BLT, and Crab Rangoon. You find a central bar, patio, dining room, and a separate pub space. The restaurant provides customers with happy hour drinking specials, making it an excellent place to visit.

11. Pizza Joe’s

Price: $22-$26 (Menu)

Address: 724 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 305-294-4546

Pizza Joe's is within a 5 minutes walking distance from the Ernest Hemingway House in Key West. It offers some of the best pizzas by the slice in Key West and has excellent customer service. The best aspect of Pizza Joe's is offering free pizzas to its first responders, which shows appreciation to its clients.

Image Credits: tripadvisor.com

What's more, they off different pizza recipes, and their New York-style thin-crust pizzas are fantastic. Most importantly, their pricing is decent. Amazingly, this place also provides frozen pizza allowing you to build your own pizza in the comfort of your home.

12. CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee

Prices: $10-$19 (Menu)

Address: 815 Sigsbee Rd Building No. V-4111, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: +1 305-834-6125

CD Anchor Food Truck Sigsbee is a family-owned food truck offering some of the Keys' most loved foods. Whatever you order from CD Anchor Food Truck's menu, you'll get it fresh, healthy, and delicious.

Image Credits: tripadvisor.com

If you're craving some dipping pizza Margherita, you can get it freshly prepared from this place. The CD Anchor Food Truck serves other dishes: Philly cheesesteaks, buffalo chicken wing fries, burgers, and cheese pizza. Additionally, they also serve fresh and healthy salads.

13. Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine

Price: $13.99 to $27.99(Menu)

Address: 1019 White St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-922-2177

Best recognized for its pizzas, soup, and salads, Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine is a casual hangout restaurant. Its pizza is unique and comes with a crispy pizza base. Their pizza Margherita is devine. On top of pizza, Oasis Cuisine is famous for its vegan, Halal, and gluten-free options.

Image Credits: ubereats.com

Additionally, the place has a friendly atmosphere for you and your family. The best bit is that it also provides indoor and outdoor seating, so you can enjoy your meals in whatever style you like. The customer service at Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine is fantastic.

Final Thoughts on the Best Pizza in Key West

Image Credits: seattlemet.com

Key West is blessed with fantastic pizza places. When you visit key west and crave a pizza, the twelve pizza places here are at your service. You should not worry. Enjoy Key West pizzas at different pizza places any time of the day. The pizzas come in various flavors and are made of multiple ingredients. You are covered if you are a cheese lover, lobster lover, or New York-made pizza lover.

Featured Image Credits: eatthis.com

author-brooklyncraftpizza

Author

JAMES BURNEY

I’m the content manager for BrooklynCraftPizza.com, and I love writing about kitchen appliances. I’m passionate about cooking at home, and I’m extremely excited about modern kitchen appliances. I like to analyze markets and products, and then turn them into informative blogs for anyone who wants to cook at home quickly. Thanks for reading!