The 18 Best Pizza Places in Green Bay, WI [Updated 2022]

Dear reader, if you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission to help support the blog - at no extra cost to you. And it never influences our product selection process. Thank you!

The 18 Best Pizza Places in Green Bay, WI [Updated 2022]

Are you someone who always organizes impromptu eat-outs? Pizza snacking with your loved ones is the best possible treats. If you were looking for the best pizza places in Green Bay, your quest is now complete.

The average American consumes pizza at least once a month, and there are 350 pieces sold every second throughout the country.

Since the late 19th century, pizza has been an integral part of the American diet. In 2017, the pizza industry was recognized as the fastest-growing section of casual restaurant chains. Considering yearly sales of $45.1 billion, you can get a good idea of how Americans love pizza.

We created a list of Green Bay's top-rated pizza restaurants. Read on to discover the next delicious pizza place near you.

Best Pizza Places in Green Bay, WI

1. Glass Nickel Pizza

Price: $10.95-$23.45 (Menu)

Address: 416 Dousman St, Green Bay, WI 54303, United States

Phone: (920) 490-1000

This Wisconsin-based pizza restaurant was founded in Madison, the state capital, and has nine separate locations today. You may order from the permanent menu of specialty pizzas like the Boaris Karloff containing three different Boar's Head meats, or the Portabella Lugosi, a rotating selection of seasonal favorites.

For vegan or lactose sensitive, they also have a Daiya Delight pizza! Not in the mood for pizza? The menu at Glass Nickel Pizza Co. also features spaghetti, salad, chicken, and shrimp.

2. Sammy's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Price: $14.95-$30.95 (Menu)

Address: 2161 S Oneida St, Green Bay, WI 54304, United States

Phone: (920) 499-6644

Sammy's is an Italian pizza joint that has been open since 1958. The reviews on TripAdvisor and Yelp clearly show that this store is a favorite among customers. Sammy's pizza uses only tried-and-true family recipes for its pizza dough, sauce, and sausage.

Additionally, they add fresh ingredients to each pizza. As a result, the cheese quality of Sammy's Pizza is superior to that of the competition. Large quantities of cheese melt and turn the mixture into the liquid.

Since then, the pizza joint has added handmade spaghetti, tagliatelle, gnocchi, fettuccine, and four different kinds of ravioli to its menu. There are also meatballs and four spaghetti sauces available.

3. Old Chicago Pizza

Price: $9.69-$22.99 (Menu)

Address: 2495 S Oneida St, Green Bay, WI 54304

Phone: (920) 884-1112

Many people from all over the world have come to love the deep-dish pizza that originated in Chicago. Additionally, the Old Chicago Pizza cordially invites you to enjoy the pizza in the superb dine-in atmosphere.

Those unfamiliar with pizza should know that Chicago pizza is known for its thick crust. Additionally, the pie has a circular form. The crust is always cooked in a square pan and is light.

The Hand-Tossed Ale Crust, which has a little ale flavor, is one of the Old Chicago Pizza crust alternatives. For those who want a gluten-free crust, there is also one available.

4. Happy Joe's Pizza & Ice Cream

Price: $6.35-$26.74 (Menu)

Address: 1675 E Mason St, Green Bay, WI 54302

Phone: (920) 465-0690

Taco Pizza is Happy Joe's most famous dish. As any fan would tell you, taco pizza is amazing. So don't leave Happy Joe's without trying the pizza with Sauer kraut on top.

If you want to sample all Happy Joe's offers, you should go on a buffet night. Many of the pizzas served here are specialty dishes. Every day, you'll also find some unique sandwich options, rich ice cream, and mouthwatering pasta dishes. Try Happy Joe's Pan Crust if you're looking for something unique.

5. Cranky Pat’s Pizza

Price: $8-$30 (Menu)

Address: 709 Bellevue St, Green Bay, WI 54302

Phone: (920) 468-7777

Since its opening in 1955, Cranky Pat's has been serving the people of the Fox Valley delicious food. This pizza shop has won several awards and is here to stay. The recipe by Pat Earle is outstanding. You can tell the ingredients in Cranky Pat's thin-crust pizza are fresh as soon as you bite it.

Cheesy toppings are standard here and piled high on Pat's special sauce. It is incredible in terms of flavor is this pizza. Some of the most popular combinations were cheese and mushrooms. Every Cranky Pat's Pizza location has a salad bar with organic greens.

6. Toppers Pizza

Price: $10-$35 (Menu)

Address: 2042 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302

Phone: (920) 432-3232

Toppers Pizza uses only genuine Wisconsin mozzarella cheese and hand-cut fresh vegetables. You can order one of the bold, savory, and distinctive House Recipe pizzas from Toppers or make your own with one of the more than one million possible combinations of their high-quality, fresh toppings.

They are well known for their bestselling brand of renowned Topperstix. They also provide both boneless and classic-style wings and Baked Mac'N Cheese as tasty side dishes.

You can place an order at your local Toppers and watch as your food is freshly created in front of you and baked in only 6 minutes, or you can buy online and have hot food delivered very quickly in just 25 minutes to your home, business, or pretty much anywhere!

7. Gallagher’s Pizza

Price: $8.99-$30 (Menu)

Address: 1651 S Webster Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301

Phone: (920) 321-5555

The great pizza at Gallagher's, which is tasty, is well known. The Irish soul and Italian tastes converge here. The outcome is the genuine Gallagher's Pizza, adding a little Chicago flare.

The pizza has bacon, macaroni, and cheese, so it's not just tasty but also filling. Rather than being baked, they are deep-fried. Gallagher's provides quick deliveries, and their delivery personnel is very courteous. You'll be happy whether you order takeout, delivery, or eat-in.

8. Pizza Ranch

Price: $10-$20 (Menu)

Address: 2206 Main Street, Green Bay, WI 54302

Phone: (920) 468-3555

It all began in 1981, when 19-year-old Adrie Groeneweg opened a shop in Hull, Iowa. There wasn't much to it. Getting pizza in this town required a trip outside of town. Pizza Ranch was founded with just six unique single-topping and specialty pizza recipes that were created around the kitchen table.

Locals in Hull loved this new eatery because of its commitment to using only fresh, locally sourced foods. Pizza Ranch flourished when the word got out. The dream that started in a young man's heart has now spread to fifteen states.

9. Jake’s Pizza Green Bay

Price: $9-$24 (Menu)

Address: 112 S Broadway, Green Bay, WI 54303

Phone: (920) 432-5253

As many as three decades have passed since Jake's Pizza first opened. Naturally, sustaining a business for so long may not be feasible unless you have a cult following.

For obvious reasons, Jake devoted 40 years of his life to the East Side, where he served Green Bay residents delicious pizza. Currently, Brook and Cara, sisters, are honored to continue the West Side history.

The store makes fresh dough, sauces, and sausage daily for your enjoyment. These pizzas can, however, take some time to prepare. The good news is that they are freshly prepared, so the wait was well worth it.

10. Back 9 Pizza & Pub

Price: $8.99-$34.99 (Menu)

Address: 1671 Hoffman Rd #50, Green Bay, WI 54311

Phone: (920) 632-2034

Here at Back 9 Pizza, you may get exactly what you're craving. The pizza at the back nine has the most delicious toppings ever. They take great pride in being the best gluten-free pizza establishment that always ensures that you will receive the best flavor. There are several options for you at the Green Bay pizza restaurant.

Whatever the occasion, the team works hard to make it special with mouthwatering snacks. As a result, back 9 Pizza is recognized as one of Green Bay's top pizzerias as they prioritize taste and quality.

11. Luigi’s Italian Bistro

Price: $8-$15.80 (Menu)

Address: 2733 Manitowoc Rd #5, Green Bay, WI 54311

Phone: (920) 468-4900

When visiting Green Bay, you must surely eat at Luigi's Italian Bistro. They make the greatest burgers around, and their pizza is unmatched. They make delicious deep-dish pizzas called "cheesy paradise."

The family-run pizzeria offers a relaxed atmosphere to eat pizza, spaghetti, and other Italian delicacies. Dine-in, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery are among the services provided.

12. Olive’s Pizza and Sandwiches

Price: $9-$30 (Menu)

Address: 516 Greene Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301

Phone: (920) 492-0732

Everyone can find something to their liking on our menu, whether they want to stick to the tried-and-true with a classic pepperoni pizza or branch out and try something new like their Thai Chicken. Their hand-tossed pizzas are delightfully crispy on the bottom while remaining soft and chewy because they are baked in a stone deck oven.

They also have a thin crust, if that's what you like, and flatbread pizzas, which are a great option for a lesser meal. But they do not sell pizza by the slice. Pizzas in the 14" and flatbread sizes and a sandwich wrap are both gluten-free options. There is enough variety for everyone to enjoy.

13. Grazies Italian Grill

Price: $12-$20 (Menu)

Address: 5327 US-10, Stevens Point, WI 54482

Phone Number: (715) 345-7808

The unique dishes of Grazies have been tried and tested by customers for years. With better ingredients for a better you and almost everything "Made Fresh from Scratch," without heat lamps or microwaves. They promise a money-well-spent event for family, friends, and loved ones.

14. Great River Roadhouse

Price: $10-$30 (Menu)

Address: 9660 WI-35, De Soto, WI 54624

Phone: (608) 648-2045

All the food at Great River Roadhouse is made from scratch, including pizza dough, chicken, ribs, and spaghetti sauce. Not only is the Great River Roadhouse pizza amazing, but the portions are also big.

Here, a small pizza will feed two adults comfortably. Italian sausage is a good companion to this. Their cuisine uses only fresh products, and they slice the veggies daily. The thin-crust pizza may be enjoyed with black olives, mushrooms, onions, pepper, and pepperoni.

15. Parker John's BBQ & Pizza

Price: $12-$32 (Menu)

Address: 9660 Wisconsin 35, De Soto, WI 54624

Phone: (608) 648-2045

Parker John's is the place to go if you can't decide between pizza and bbq! To get your appetite going, try an order of the Sconnie fries, and then see if you can handle one of their enormous pizzas.

Triple P Pizza is a safe bet if you're unsure what to get. This pizza features pulled pork topped with melted Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella cheese and finger-licking barbecue sauce.

16. Strada Pizzeria

Price: $16.95-$18.95 (Menu)

Address: 109 N Broadway, De Pere, WI 54115

Phone: (920) 425-7014

In search of real Italian-style pizza? Strada Pizzeria is the only place to go. The crust is the most important factor in this case. The crust at Strada Pizzeria is airy, light, and crunchy. You should give it a shot on your own to see how it works.

This street pizza tends to melt in your mouth. Even some customers describe it as "life-changing." Slices, whole pies, and everything in between is always on the menu at Strada Pizzeria, whether you eat in or take out. Additionally, the store offers curbside pickup, but you must make such arrangements in advance by calling.

17. T J Grizzlies

Price: $11-$21 (Menu)

Address: 4283 Co Hwy, Land O' Lakes, WI 54540

Phone: (715) 547-3700

TJ Grizzlies is not necessary for my ranking of Green Bay's top pizzerias. Every time you order pizza, it is freshly cooked. Additionally, they serve freshly baked sandwiches and handmade pasta.

Additionally, you are free to design your pizza to sate your hunger. The T J Grizzlies serves a variety of specialty pizzas. One of them is the BBQ Chicken Pizza, which is created with grilled chicken breast, authentic Wisconsin mozzarella, and Sweet Baby Ray's barbecue sauce.

The best veggie pizza can be found at T J Grizzlies for the family vegetarian. Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and black and green olives can all be added as toppings. You might also like to try one of the daily changing fresh and hot handmade soups.

18. Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge

Price: $16.50-$23.50 (Menu)

Address: 13201 Velp Ave, Suamico, WI 54313

Phone: (920) 544-9379

Located in an ancient chapel in historic downtown Suamico, Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge has served the community for over 112 years. Pizza comes in various flavors, including vegan and gluten-free options.

Vegetarians, vegans, and those following a gluten-free diet can all find something to enjoy at this pizzeria. They use various tasty, fresh ingredients to top their thin-crust pizzas. It would be ideal for your upcoming family reunion, work dinner, or dating night.

Conclusion

If you happen to be an enthusiast when it comes to pizzas, your opinion would be much appreciated. Do you know where to find the best pizza from mom-and-pop shops in your state?

Would you bring your pizza stone if someone invited you to a pizza party? Answering these questions will help you determine the best spots to buy pizza in Green Bay, Wisconsin.

author-brooklyncraftpizza

Author

JAMES BURNEY

I’m the content manager for BrooklynCraftPizza.com, and I love writing about kitchen appliances. I’m passionate about cooking at home, and I’m extremely excited about modern kitchen appliances. I like to analyze markets and products, and then turn them into informative blogs for anyone who wants to cook at home quickly. Thanks for reading!